How to Decide Between a Wedding and an Elopement

So you’re engaged, now what?! Time to plan the day you commit to sharing your life with another human. Yeah, it’s kind of a big deal.

The first thing you should do is imagine what the day looks like. Are you surrounded by 100+ people cheering for you and your new spouse as you walk down the aisle after your first kiss? Maybe, you see yourself sitting at the dinner table with your sweetheart looking out all the people in your life that brought you to this day. Maybe, you picture a big dance party at the end of the night.

Or, do you picture something totally different? Do you imagine being on a mountaintop gazing at sweeping views during sunset, just you two. You have just hiked to your dream ceremony location where it’s remote, quiet, and the only thing keeping you to a schedule is the daylight. You picture yourselves starting your life together with an adventure.

This decision can be way more complicated than you may have previously anticipated and I’m here to help you figure out what is best for you two.

Newlyweds Walking Down the Aisle

Should you have a Wedding or an Elopement?

Weddings


  • Average cost of a wedding in Seattle is $25,000-$30,000
  • Whoever is paying for the wedding feels entitled to have a say in the planning
  • Average time couples take to plan a wedding is 1 year
  • It’s like throwing the biggest most elaborate party of your life
  • You get to celebrate with everyone you know and love
  • In some cases, you are obligated to invite a lot of people you don’t care about
  • There is a potential to hurt a lot of friends and families feelings for not being invited
  • Sticking to a timeline is important because there’s a lot of moving parts
  • All eyes are on you! You’re hosting a huge event and are the center of attention
  • There can be social pressure to provide a baller event for your guests (good food, decorations, music, etc)
 

Elopements


  • Cost of an elopement can range from $100-$15,000 (depending if it’s a destination and if there’s any vendor’s involved)
  • Less pressure to consider other people’s opinions or expectations while planning
  • Couples take anywhere from 1 week to 1 year to plan an elopement
  • You spend more time with each other and are really able to be present
  • You CAN include a small group of your family and friends
  • There is a potential to hurt a lot of friends and families feelings for not being invited
  • The day is relaxed, you’re at your leisure, sticking to a timeline isn’t crucial
  • You’re not the center of attention of a huge event
  • You can incorporate an adventure or an activity you love (rock climbing, hiking, kayaking, etc)
Stephanie Keegan and a newly eloped couple on a mountain in Yosemite

My experiences (both as a bride and a photographer)

 

There are so many different factors to consider while making your decision between having a wedding and an elopement when you’re trying to please everyone. And right there is the key phrase, “trying to please everyone”. That’s what really makes it difficult, don’t you think? I know for me it did! If you are bold, don’t care what other people think and don’t want to put anyone else’s feelings before your own for how you want to get married, then that’s awesome! But if you don’t work that way, then the decision is really hard.

Obviously, no one else should make this decision for you, especially not me. But, I can tell you what I know. I have been a bride of a big wedding, I have photographed weddings, and I have been a guest to elopements and have also photographed elopements. I’m sure that the experience of being the couple who is eloping is much different than photographing it, but here’s what I have learned and observed over the years.

Bride and groom entering their wedding

Weddings

 

When I got married, my husband and I wanted to throw a huge party and celebrate with everyone. We went all out with 200 guests with the typical obligatory invites and also the invites where if you include this one person, you have to include these other 7 people.

The day was fast-paced, jam packed, and fun as HECK. It was the best day ever. Being able to gather all the people that we knew and loved in one place to celebrate was freaking awesome.

We had the best dance party at the end of the night, got super sweaty and messed up my hair REAL bad and it was the dream wedding we’ve always wanted.

That said, it was also incredibly stressful. I don’t enjoy being in the center of attention because I’m introverted and I don’t have an endless social battery like my husband does. The planning process was fun but those last few weeks were anxiety-filled. The entire day, I felt like I wasn’t really in my body, like I was watching a lot of it go by because there were only a handful of moments I found to really soak it all in and be present.

My honest to god favorite part of my day was right after the ceremony when my husband and I got 15 minutes completely alone in the bridal suite. I took off my dress, we ate a plate of food, and laid on the ground together.

It was the only time we got to be alone the entire day. We wouldn’t have done it any other way though! But if we were to get married now, we’d elope in the mountains and have a little reception afterwards.

As a photographer, I get to follow around the couple most of the day. I am able to observe them, their emotions, interactions, and private moments. Here’s what I’ve observed:

  • It’s an emotional roller coaster (not necessarily in a good or bad way)

  • Lots of love, support, and hugs from all the guests

  • There’s the feeling of anticipation before the first look, followed by the indescribable joy when you see each other for the first time

  • So many smiles and laughing during wedding party photos

  • Family photos are a stressor because the couple is tired of standing and smiling. Also, family members aren’t listening so it takes forever and the couple just wants to get to their cocktail hour and join the rest of the guests

  • The couple spends only 50% of the whole day physically together, and of that time, maybe 5% completely alone

  • Lot’s of tears and laugher during toasts

  • Couples seem to have the most fun and feel most relaxed during the big dance party at the end of the night

I have also seen many couples feel overwhelmed, stressed out, annoyed, frustrated, and disappointed. I have even helped a bride through a full on panic attack right before the ceremony.

When you throw a huge party after planning it for over a year, there is a good chance some things might not go as planned! From my observations, I have noticed that couples experience the most anxiety stress from problems that arise because of their FAMILY (sound about right?).

I feel weird saying it, but it’s true. Very rarely, do I see couples getting frustrated over the fact that the food is cold which can seem like a terrible thing to have happen but it’s honestly just brushed off because it’s out of their control.

The things I see couples upset over are family members being pushy or demanding. Sounds like not too big of a deal, but it can be. When it’s your wedding, you want to feel like it’s a celebration of your love. Even if you are introverted and don’t like being the center of attention, you still want your wedding to be about you two as a couple and your marriage and it totally should be!

But when you have family telling you what to do, where to be, making it about them, it gets overwhelming and exhausting. It makes you feel like this isn’t your wedding, like it’s someone else’s party and you’re just the shiny toy being passed around.

This can create that feeling like you’re just watching the day go by as others take over and not really participating in it the way you wanted to.

All these ups and downs are simply the realities of having a wedding. It’s not always the case, as I have seen couples loving every aspect of their wedding day. But typically, there is some combination of all these emotions that couples experience on the day of their wedding. Here’s the secret:

It’s all about the perception and mentally you decide to have going into your wedding. If you accept that things might go wrong, it will be easily brushed off when they do.

If you know that your mom is going to be overbearing, you can find it endearing. If you know that crazy Paul might get too drunk and accidentally knock over the cake table, you can hopefully appoint a “babysitter” or just find some hilarity in the fact that he can’t keep his shit together. If you know in your heart that all your guests are there because they love and support you and they’re not just there to sabotage your day, you’ll see that they are just there to celebrate with you in the only way they know how.

Bride and groom hiking in Washington State

Elopements

 

First, what is an elopement? It used to be a word to describe couples “running away” and getting married in secret. While that is still a definition of the word, it has been adapted over the years to describe something totally different. And YES, you can have guests! I have seen anywhere from just the couple and their officiant, to 20 loved ones involved. From being in the wedding industry and photographing elopements, here is a description of what it looks like:

An elopement is an intentionally intimate celebration of marriage where the couple is able have an authentic experience. The couple is able to create an experience that is a reflection of who they are without the social pressure and expectations of a traditional wedding.

Some of the reasons couples elope

  • You can put your money toward your future (house, kids, etc) rather than a big party

  • You don’t feel that your relationship is supported by your family

  • You want to spend all that money on a big experience (trip to Patagonia where you ride a helicopter to the ceremony location, etc)

  • It often takes less time and stress to plan

  • There is family drama you want to avoid

  • You don’t like being the center of attention

  • You want photos of you two in a place you love or is meaningful to you

  • One or both of you have been married before with a big wedding and it wasn’t a great experience

When I’ve been a guest at elopement ceremonies, it was because the couple didn’t want to deal with the drama and planning of a wedding. They were also not very close with their families and considered their friends to be their family. It was about spending time with a small group of people that meant the world to them, rather than a hundred people they would have felt obligated to invite.

Being a guest at an elopement is freaking awesome because you get to actually spend your time WITH the couple. And you know you’ve been invited there because the couple wants to actually spend time with you.

From my experiences photographing couples eloping, here are the things that I’ve observed:

  • The couple is excited but relaxed

  • The couples are able to be present and take each moment in BECAUSE they are relaxed

  • The timeline for the day is fluid, not super strict

  • The weather is unpredictable and if you’re miles from the car there’s no avoiding it

  • The couple decides every aspect of the day and isn’t told what to do or where to be

  • The couple seems very in their element, being outdoors where they feel the happiest

  • The guests have a lot of fun and appreciate the genuine time spent with the couple

  • Sometimes, compromises have to be made like not having a hair and makeup artist, depending on the location of the ceremony

  • Wedding dresses can get trashed but most of the brides go into it knowing that will be the case and are okay with it

  • The couple received incredible photos from their day out in the wilderness!

Elopements can look like whatever you want. The word “elopement” can seem limiting or specific, but it simply means an intentionally small wedding ceremony. This means, YOU CAN STILL INCLUDE YOUR FAMILY! I want to emphasize that because some couples think that eloping means it’s just you two, but that’s not necessarily the case. But if you have an elderly grandparent coming, it might mean that you have to choose a ceremony location that is easily accessible which is totally doable!

Couple relaxing at Colchuck Lake

Understanding where the stress comes from

You might be wondering, why can it be so stressful? Why does a wedding or an elopement have to be stressful at all? Well, it doesn’t have to be stressful, but there are going to be potential stressors. The reality of having a wedding is that you’re hosting a huge party. It’s a party where you’ve invited everyone you know and that you’ve been preparing for and planning for sometimes over a year. And if you’re like me, you’ve been low key planning it since you were 8 years old. It’s a HUGE event in your life to have happen in one day and I mean not to mention, there’s also that aspect of getting married to some weirdo that you’ve deemed acceptable to spend the rest of your life with. You want everything to go perfectly as planned (it never does, literally ever) and that’s a lot of pressure on one day.

For elopements, there’s a whole different kind of stress involved. If you’ve decided to have a mountaintop elopement, you might have to worry about inclement weather. You could be dealing with unexpected storms that can introduce some real danger. There could be stress around the logistics if you’re hoping to get to a certain spot at a certain time. If you’ve chosen a popular hike or location, there could be crowds gathering in the spot you were hoping to have your ceremony at.

Still Can’t Decide? An intimate wedding might be your thing!

Does a big wedding just seem too overwhelming but an elopement seems too exclusive? Try thinking about an intimate wedding! An intimate wedding is considered to be anywhere from 20-50 guests and can be a great to have those big wedding feels with the intimacy of an elopement.

The Takeaway

So you see, there are a lot of things to consider when making the decision between a wedding and elopement. I could be as simple as, “just decide on whatever sounds best to you”, but some of us want to know what our pros and cons might be since everyone’s are different. The reality is that both options are a fantastic choice, but they both have their own set of potential stressors.

Again, it’s all about your perception and mentality going into it. If you think of a wedding as a big, fun party (drama included) with all your loved ones, it will be just that. If you think of your elopement as an adventure (possible rain and ruining your dress), it will be just that!

The bottom line is, this is about YOU, who you are as a couple, what you value, and how you want to start the rest of your lives together. If you try to please others, you’re not going to have your dream day and then what would be the point of it all?!

Hey! I'm Stephanie.

I'm an adventure elopement photographer based in the Pacific Northwest. My job is to help couples craft and document their dream day in the outdoors.

Elopement Resources